Scotch drinkers: what's one bottle you'd hand someone to convert them from bourbon?

Most bourbon drinkers I know say they "don't like scotch" — but what they really mean is they tried Johnnie Walker Red at a college party and wrote off an entire category. I've been on a mission to convert my bourbon-loving friends and I've had the most success with Balvenie 14 Caribbean Cask. The rum barrel finish gives it enough sweetness and tropical fruit to bridge the gap from bourbon, without the peat that scares people off. Plus the price (~$70) is reasonable enough that they don't feel like they wasted money if they hate it. What's your go-to conversion bottle? Bonus points if it works on someone who thinks all scotch tastes like a campfire.

6 replies

Replies (3)

RB Rob B.Jan 26, 2026

GlenDronach 12. Sherry bomb, fruit cake, chocolate — everything a bourbon drinker already loves, just in scotch form. It's like a translator between the two worlds. Around $55-60 and it absolutely destroys at that price point.

PD Paul D.Jan 27, 2026

Monkey Shoulder. I know it's a blend and the scotch purists will come for me, but it's $30, it's smooth, it's approachable, and nobody has ever tasted it and said "this is terrible." It's the gateway drug of scotch. Once they're in, you can start pushing them toward the single malts.

SS Sippin' SarahJan 27, 2026

Aberlour A'bunadh. Yes, it's cask strength and yes, it's intense — but with a few drops of water it opens up into this rich Christmas pudding flavor that bourbon drinkers go absolutely crazy for. The sherry influence is enormous. Fair warning: it's around $90, so this is a "special occasion conversion" bottle.