- The mildest Connecticut here, in my smokes
- Clean construction and a consistent burn
- 18 to 20 cents a minute
- Too gentle if you already like body

Ten mild and mild-to-medium cigars I have smoked and timed, from 30 to 70 minutes, with my local shop's single prices, what each minute costs, and the order I'd smoke them in.
Read us first
Make BoozeMakers your preferred source for booze reviews on Google
One tap puts our reviews above the sponsored noise in your Search and AI Overviews. Five seconds, no signup.
| Award | Product | Score | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Best Overall | Ashton Classic Esquire The mildest of the Connecticuts for Rob, 45 to 50 minutes for about $9 | 91 | Jump to review |
| Short on Time | Arturo Fuente Hemingway Short Story Finish it clean in 30 to 35 minutes | 91 | Jump to review |
| Training Wheels | Baccarat The Game Robusto The sweet tip takes the edge off while you learn the draw | 88 | Jump to review |
| Next Step | My Father Flor de las Antillas Toro 94/100, richer, for after two or three milder cigars | 89 | Jump to review |
Ashton Classic Esquire
The mildest of the Connecticuts for Rob, 45 to 50 minutes for about $9
Arturo Fuente Hemingway Short Story
Finish it clean in 30 to 35 minutes
Baccarat The Game Robusto
The sweet tip takes the edge off while you learn the draw
My Father Flor de las Antillas Toro
94/100, richer, for after two or three milder cigars
The first cigar I ever smoked is #3 on this list: a Macanudo Café Corona, on a buddy's back deck around 2011. I have smoked all ten cigars below and timed them. They run from 30 minutes to 70, and at the single prices I pay at my local shop they cost between 16 and 40 cents a minute.
That Macanudo was mild, with no drama. It didn't blow my mind, but it didn't punish me either, and that was enough to keep me interested. That is the job of a beginner cigar, and every pick here is one I would hand to someone starting out.
| Cigar | Our score | My smoking time | My shop's single price | Per minute |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ashton Classic Esquire | 91 | 45 to 50 min | $9 | 18 to 20¢ |
| Fuente Hemingway Short Story | 91 | 30 to 35 min | $11 to $12 | 31 to 40¢ |
| Macanudo Café Corona | 88 | 45 to 50 min | $10 to $11 | 20 to 24¢ |
| Oliva Connecticut Reserve Robusto | 89 | 50 to 60 min | $11 to $12 | 18 to 24¢ |
| Montecristo White Series Toro | 89 | 60 to 70 min | $15 to $16 | 21 to 27¢ |
| Rocky Patel Vintage 1999 Connecticut | 89 | 55 to 65 min | $12 to $13 | 18 to 24¢ |
| Perdomo 10th Anniversary Champagne | 90 | 50 min | $9 | 18¢ |
| Drew Estate Undercrown Shade Gran Toro | 89 | 55 min | $9 | 16¢ |
| My Father Flor de las Antillas Toro | 94 | 50 to 60 min | $12 to $13 | 20 to 26¢ |
| Baccarat The Game Robusto | 85 | 40 to 45 min | $7 to $8 | 16 to 20¢ |
Per minute is the shop price divided by the smoking time, low price over long time to high price over short time. The prices are the rough single prices I paid at my local shop as of November 2026. Your shop will differ, because cigar taxes vary by state, so run the same division on your own receipt.
What this means when you buy: the Short Story is the shortest cigar here and the most expensive per minute, at up to double the Ashton Esquire. That is not a reason to skip it. It is the one I hand to a beginner who might not sit still, because you can finish it clean in half an hour. But if you have a full evening, the Ashton, Perdomo, Undercrown, Oliva or Rocky Patel gives you 45 to 65 minutes at 16 to 24 cents a minute. Pick the cigar by the time you have, then by the price.
I smoked too fast. I treated my first cigars like cigarettes and kept the end roaring. The result was a hot, bitter mess and a headache. If the cigar feels hot near the band, you are puffing too often. Our guide to how to smoke a cigar covers the pace.
I let a shop talk me into a full-bodied cigar. The salesman pushed a Padrón 1964 "because you'll grow into it." I smoked it too early. It overpowered everything, went bitter and heavy, and I put it down halfway. It is a great cigar (see our Padrón 1964 review), but not at that stage. Ignore the "you'll grow into it" pitch until you have some miles under your belt. A cigar you put down at halfway costs you half its price for nothing.
A couple of the Connecticuts needed a quick touch-up with the lighter once. None of the ten turned into a constant fight.
No. I started with an inexpensive Boveda humidity bag and a handful of singles, and did that for months before I bought anything permanent. There is no reason to spend money on a full humidor until you are sure you are sticking with it. When you are, see how to store cigars at home and our best humidors.
I buy mostly from local shops, as singles and 5-packs, and buy online only when I already know exactly what I want. That is the case for buying singles first: you find out which of these you like for $7 to $16 a cigar, not the price of a box.
Black coffee, or a light rum that stays out of the way of a mild Connecticut. I reach for Bacardi 8 on the slightly richer side, or Plantation 3 Stars when I want something lighter and cleaner. Plantation is now sold as Planteray, so look for that name on the shelf. Neither is something we have reviewed yet. For more rum, see our top 10 rums. If you drink bourbon, our cigar and bourbon pairing guide covers that side.
I smoke mostly on the back patio in the evening, sometimes in a quiet corner at the golf course after a round. Never while driving, and never indoors unless the place is built for it.
On November 11, 2026 we rebuilt this guide from my own notes. Earlier versions described eleven picks, a starter kit and a Padrón 2000 that were not on the page, bourbon pairings the entries did not include, and a testing process and scoring formula we cannot document. Those are gone. What is left is what I have smoked, timed and paid for.
Need gear to go with them? See our cigar accessories guide, or give the hobby as a gift with one of the best drinks-club gifts.
Rob Boirun - The Bourbon Baron
Rob has smoked cigars since around 2011, when his first was a Macanudo Café Corona, #3 on this list. He has smoked all ten cigars here, mostly on his back patio, and buys mostly as singles and 5-packs from local shops.
Editorial independence notice: Boozemakers maintains full editorial independence. We purchase all products at retail and are never compensated for our reviews. Affiliate links may earn us a commission at no extra cost to you.
Our editor, Rob, has smoked every cigar on this page. Scores come from each cigar's full BoozeMakers review. Smoking times are from his own smokes, and prices are the rough single prices he paid at his local shop as of November 2026.
Cost per minute is the price divided by the smoking time, given as a range from the low price over the long time to the high price over the short time.
A mild or mild-to-medium cigar with a full BoozeMakers review that Rob would hand to someone starting out, plus one medium-bodied step-up.
Next update planned: October 2026
Rebuilt from Rob's own notes: smoking times, local-shop single prices, cost per minute, the order to smoke them in, and two beginner mistakes. Removed references to eleven picks, a starter kit, a Padrón 2000 and bourbon pairings that were not on the page, plus an undocumented testing process and scoring formula. Added the Perdomo 10th Anniversary Champagne and the Drew Estate Undercrown Shade.
Initial publication.